Fede Cocina

Recipes

How to Make Homemade Cream Cheese with Milk and Lemon

By 4 min readUpdated

In short

Homemade cream cheese is made by heating 1 liter of milk until it's almost boiling, curdling it with 60 ml of lemon juice, and letting it rest covered for about 30 minutes. Then you drain it in a clean cloth and process it with salt and a splash of milk. A food processor needs less liquid than a blender, and it firms up in the fridge.

Watch it onInstagramYouTube

Did you know you can make a spreadable cream cheese with just milk and lemon? Two ingredients, a pot, a clean cloth, and a food processor. The rest is waiting half an hour and adjusting the texture to your liking.

I use 1 liter of milk and 60 ml of lemon juice, plus a pinch of salt and a splash of extra milk for texture. The step-by-step is in my cream cheese recipe. Here I'll explain what you're actually making, the details that matter most, and how to choose between a blender and a food processor.

What this homemade cream cheese really is

What you're doing is curdling hot milk with an acid and keeping the solid part. It's the same principle as paneer, the fresh cheese from India, which is made by adding lemon juice, vinegar, or citric acid to hot milk to separate the curds from the whey, then draining them in a cloth.

It's not the same as store-bought cream cheese, and that's fine. Argentina's food code defines commercial cream cheese as one made with whole milk and cream, acidified with lactic acid bacteria cultures and set with rennet or enzymes. The homemade version is simpler, which is why I call it "homemade cream cheese" and don't compare it to the boxed kind.

Step 1: the milk, just below a boil

Heat the milk in a pot until it's about to boil, when it's just starting to bubble. It doesn't need to boil. Stir every now and then so the bottom doesn't scorch. Once it gets there, turn off the heat and take it off the burner.

Step 2: the lemon and the half hour

Add the lemon and stir a little. If you don't have lemon, vinegar works. You'll see the milk start to separate right away.

Cover the pot and let it rest for about 30 minutes so the acid can do its job. In the end you have two parts: white lumps (the curds) and a yellowish liquid, the whey. If you want to understand what's happening to the proteins at that point, I explain it in why lemon curdles milk.

Step 3: drain it, without obsessing

Set a clean cloth over a bowl, pour everything in, and gather up the corners. Lift it and twist it so the whey drips out. Any fabric works, as long as it's really clean.

You don't need to squeeze out every last drop. If a little whey stays in, no problem: you just don't want it too runny later.

Step 4: food processor or blender

The solids go into the food processor with a pinch of salt and a small splash of milk. Process for 30 seconds to a minute, check it, and if you want it smoother, add milk a little at a time and process again.

It also works in a blender, but you'll have to add a lot more milk to get it moving. KitchenAid explains why: a blender works with a vortex that depends on the mixture flowing, and thick mixtures don't circulate well; a food processor, with its wide, shallow bowl, handles thick mixtures better.

Food processorBlender
Extra milkA splashQuite a bit more
TextureNice and thick, spreadableSofter and runnier
WhyWide bowl, handles thick mixturesNeeds liquid for the vortex

Don't panic if it looks runny

Right after making it, it may look too soft. In the fridge, after a couple of hours, it firms up. There's a reason: in a study in the Journal of Dairy Science, every spreadable cheese tested was firmer and less spreadable at 10 °C (50 °F) than at 22 °C (72 °F).

So think about the texture when cold. If you want it firm out of the fridge, don't add as much milk in the processor.

Two things to watch

  • Use fresh milk in good condition. Milk you curdle on purpose with lemon is perfectly fine to eat. Milk that curdles on its own in the fridge is a different story, and you shouldn't drink it.
  • Keep it in the fridge in a clean container as soon as it's done.

What to use it for

Spread it on bread or crackers, use it in a sauce, or in sweet recipes. For example, it's perfect in a chocotorta, the Argentine no-bake chocolate cookie cake.

The recap: milk just below a boil, lemon, half an hour covered, drain without obsessing, food processor with salt and milk added a little at a time, and patience while the fridge does its thing.

Frequently asked questions

Can you make cream cheese with vinegar instead of lemon?

Yes. Vinegar curdles hot milk just like lemon does: what matters is the acid.

Is it the same as store-bought cream cheese?

No. Commercial cream cheese is made with whole milk and cream, lactic acid cultures, and rennet or enzymes. The milk-and-lemon version is closer to a fresh cheese like paneer.

Why is my homemade cream cheese runny?

Because it's freshly made or you added too much milk while processing. It firms up in the fridge; next time, add the milk a little at a time.

Do you have to boil the milk to make cream cheese?

No: it's enough to heat it until it's about to boil, when it's just starting to bubble.

Related recipes

Sources

The facts in this post come from these sources (checked when it was written).

  1. Cómo preparar queso crema — Fede Cocina (YouTube) (2021)
  2. Paneer — Wikipedia
  3. Quesos (resumen del Código Alimentario Argentino), revista Alimentos Argentinos n.º 46 — Ministerio de Agricultura, Ganadería y Pesca de la Argentina
  4. Thick mixtures: blender vs food processor — KitchenAid Australia
  5. Viscoelasticity and texture of spreadable cheeses with different fat contents at refrigeration and room temperatures — Journal of Dairy Science 95(12):6926-6936 (Bayarri, Carbonell y Costell) (2012)

More from the blog

See the whole blog →