Fede Cocina

Tips

How to Tell If Honey Is Real (and Why Home Tests Don't Work)

By 4 min readUpdated

In short

There's no reliable way to tell at home whether honey is pure. The glass-of-water test catches honey diluted with water, but not honey mixed with syrup, and even in a lab a single test isn't enough. Honey turning solid isn't a sign it's fake: natural honey crystallizes on its own. Your best bets are reading the label carefully, buying from a beekeeper or brand you trust, and being wary of prices that are too low.

You've probably seen the tricks: drop a spoonful into a glass of water, put a drop on your thumb, try to light it with a match. They all promise to tell you in a minute whether the honey you bought is real.

I have bad news: none of them is reliable. And the reason is more interesting than the trick.

The glass-of-water test

The idea is that pure honey sinks to the bottom in one piece and diluted honey dissolves. It's the only home trick I found tested in a study: students at the University of British Columbia, in Canada, ran it and published it in their student science journal.

They measured how much weight the honey lost after some time in the water. Honey diluted with water lost about 64 %: there, the trick worked. But honey mixed with corn syrup lost only about 5 %, much closer to pure honey than to the diluted one. In other words, the honey with syrup passed almost as if it were real.

And that's exactly the problem, because today honey gets cut with syrups, not water.

What about the thumb and the match?

I couldn't find any serious study backing them. They get repeated from video to video, but nobody has shown that they can tell pure honey from honey with syrup.

Even a lab can't rely on one test

If it's any comfort, the problem isn't just yours. The European Commission's Joint Research Centre says current analytical methods are not yet developed enough at the international level, and that a single simple test isn't enough to detect adulteration. If a lab struggles, a glass of water doesn't stand a chance.

The solid honey myth

The other myth you hear most is "if it turned solid, it's not real." It's the other way around.

Argentina's Ministry of Agriculture says it plainly: crystallization is a natural process in honey, which can be liquid, solid, or creamy. And the U.S. National Honey Board explains why: most honeys contain more glucose than they can keep dissolved, and that glucose crystallizes on its own at room temperature.

Honey turning solid doesn't prove it's pure, but it's not a sign that it's fake either. If you want to know more about that, I explain it in does honey expire.

Why would anyone cut honey?

Money. According to the Joint Research Centre, honey imported into the European Union cost an average of €2.32 per kilo in 2021, while rice syrups are available at €0.40-0.60 per kilo. A kilo of syrup costs less than a quarter of a kilo of honey.

And the syrups have changed. Corn syrup, the one the water test caught best, is now rarely used to extend honey: it's been replaced by syrups made mostly from rice, wheat, or sugar beet.

Nearly half of the honey imported into Europe was suspicious

Between November 2021 and February 2022, the European Union tested 320 honey consignments from 20 countries. Of those samples, 147, or 46 %, were suspected of being adulterated.

Read that carefully: it's honey coming into Europe from other countries, not all the honey in the world. But it gives you an idea of how common it is.

So how do you choose honey?

At home, there's no reliable way to know. What you can do is choose better:

  1. Read the whole label. Argentina's Ministry of Agriculture warns that "honey" is not the same as a "honey-based food," and that some products use the word honey without containing it, or with very little.
  2. Know what it should be. Under the Argentine Food Code, honey must not contain any substance foreign to its composition. If the label adds syrups or sugars, it isn't pure honey.
  3. Buy from someone you trust. A beekeeper you know or a brand you trust is the safest bet there is.
  4. Be wary of the price. If a honey is much cheaper than all the others, what makes it so cheap is usually the syrup.
SignDoes it tell you it's pure?
It sinks in a glass of waterNo: honey with syrup passes too
It crystallizedNo: natural honey crystallizes on its own
It says "honey-based food"Yes: it isn't pure honey
Price far below the restIt's a red flag

And once you have a good one, keep it tightly closed, between 18 and 24 °C (64 and 75 °F), as the Ministry recommends: it'll last a very long time.

Frequently asked questions

Is crystallized honey fake?

No. Crystallization is a natural process: the glucose in honey crystallizes on its own over time.

What does “honey-based food” on a label mean?

That it isn't pure honey: it's a product that contains honey, sometimes very little, along with other ingredients.

What is honey adulterated with?

Mostly sugar syrups. In Europe, the most common today are made from rice, wheat, or sugar beet; corn syrup is rarely used.

How should you store honey?

In an airtight container, in a cool, dry place away from light, between 18 and 24 °C (64 and 75 °F).

Sources

The facts in this post come from these sources (checked when it was written).

  1. Debunking the Rumoured Water Test for Honey Purity Testing — Expedition (revista estudiantil, Universidad de Columbia Británica)
  2. Food fraud: How genuine is your honey? — Centro Común de Investigación (JRC), Comisión Europea (2023)
  3. Shelf Life and Stability of Honey — National Honey Board (copia en BJCP)
  4. Información al consumidor (apicultura) — Ministerio de Agricultura, Ganadería y Pesca de la Argentina

More from the blog

See the whole blog →