Fede Cocina

Kitchen science

Why Does Sugar Crystallize and Turn Sandy?

By 5 min readUpdated

In short

Sugar crystallizes because a concentrated syrup becomes supersaturated as it cools: it holds more sugar than the water can sustain. 100 g of water dissolves about 200 g of sugar cold and almost 480 g at a boil. Stirring and surfaces, like the peanuts in garrapiñadas, get crystals started, and one calls the next until everything turns to sand.

When you make caramel, the big fear is that the syrup crystallizes and turns into white sand. With garrapiñadas, the candied peanuts sold on the streets of Argentina and Uruguay, that's exactly what happens, and it's exactly what you want. What ruins a caramel is what makes this recipe.

Here's why sugar turns to sand, why stirring sets it off, and why, if you keep going over low heat, that sand turns back into caramel.

How much sugar can water hold?

Far more than you'd think, and it depends on temperature. Using the sucrose solubility equation from a 2023 study in Physics of Fluids, 100 g of water at 20 °C (68 °F) can dissolve about 200 g of sugar: twice its weight. At a boil, close to 480 g, almost five times.

I ran the numbers on my garrapiñadas recipe, which uses 150 g of sugar with just enough water to moisten it. To dissolve those 150 g cold, you'd need about 75 g of water; at a boil, about 31 g is enough. That's why, with so little water, it's the heat that finishes dissolving the sugar. The Exploratorium, San Francisco's science museum, puts it simply: the higher the temperature, the more sugar can stay dissolved.

Boiling drives off the water

As the syrup boils, the water evaporates. According to the Exploratorium, as a sugar syrup cooks, water boils away, the sugar concentration rises, and so does the temperature. At the thread stage, between 110 and 113 °C (230 and 235 °F), the syrup is already about 80 % sugar.

That's what's happening when, in my recipe, I wait for the syrup to "thicken just a little" before adding the peanuts. I don't use a thermometer, so I can't give you the exact number for that moment.

Supersaturated: more sugar than it can hold

Here's the key. A syrup that's 80 % sugar is fine while it's hot. But as it cools, the water can no longer hold that much sugar dissolved. By my math with the same equation, below about 86 °C (187 °F) there's sugar left over. The Exploratorium says the solution becomes supersaturated.

A supersaturated syrup is unstable: it's just waiting for an excuse to crystallize. And the garrapiñadas pot gives it plenty. The peanuts and almonds go in at room temperature, so the syrup that touches them cools instantly and becomes supersaturated right there, clinging to each nut.

One crystal calls the next

What sets it all off is movement and surfaces. The Physics of Fluids study says that in a supersaturated sucrose solution, agitation promotes fast crystallization. And that crystals most commonly start on a foreign surface: the walls of the pot, the air, dust. The Exploratorium agrees: stirring or jostling of any kind can make sugar start to crystallize.

With garrapiñadas you have both: you stir nonstop and every peanut is a surface. One crystal forms, that crystal seeds the next one, and within a couple of minutes the whole pot turns to sand. That's why, with flan caramel, the advice is the opposite: don't touch it while it cooks.

Is it ruined? No: it's solid sugar again

That white sand is sucrose crystals, solid sugar stuck to the peanuts. Nobody has measured the crystal size in garrapiñadas, but there's a useful comparison: in fondant, another candy made by crystallizing a syrup while working it, the same study says the ideal crystals measure between 1 and 20 micrometers, thousandths of a millimeter.

Over low heat, it turns back into caramel

If you stop here, you get white garrapiñadas. If you turn the heat back on to the lowest setting and keep stirring, the crystals start to melt and turn into caramel. On the Exploratorium's chart, light caramel is at 160 °C (320 °F), brown at 170 °C (338 °F), and burnt at 177 °C (350 °F).

A curious detail: sugar doesn't have a fixed melting point. In a 2004 study in Carbohydrate Research, sucrose started melting at 184.5 °C (364 °F) when heated at 1 degree per minute, and at 188.9 °C (372 °F) at 10 degrees per minute. And at the slow rate, it started breaking down earlier, at 171 °C (340 °F). The safe way to put it is that as sugar melts, it's already breaking apart: that's caramel. I dig into it in what happens to sugar when it caramelizes.

Industry does the same thing you do in the pot: a Procter & Gamble patent describes crystallizing sugar onto raw peanuts and then melting only part of those crystals, between 5 % and 50 %. If too little melts, the coating turns out grainy.

StageWhat happens to the sugar
Boiling syrupIt dissolves and the water evaporates
It hits the cold peanutsIt becomes supersaturated
You stirOne crystal calls the next: sand
Lowest heatThe crystals melt into caramel
177 °C (350 °F)It burns

The step-by-step for making them at home, with the three stages of the sugar, is in how to make garrapiñadas at home.

Frequently asked questions

How do I keep caramel syrup from crystallizing?

Don't stir it while it cooks: agitating a concentrated syrup, or crystals falling from the sides of the pan, can set off crystallization.

How much sugar dissolves in water?

100 g of water at 20 °C (68 °F) holds about 200 g of sugar; at a boil, close to 480 g, almost five times its weight.

Can crystallized sugar be saved?

Yes: it's just solid sugar again. In garrapiñadas, over low heat, those crystals melt and turn into caramel.

What temperature does sugar melt at?

It has no fixed point: in one study it started melting between 184.5 °C (364 °F) and 188.9 °C (372 °F) depending on the heating rate, and was already breaking down before that.

Related recipes

Sources

The facts in this post come from these sources (checked when it was written).

  1. Cómo hacer garrapiñadas fácil y rápido — Fede Cocina (YouTube) (2021)
  2. Crystallization in highly supersaturated, agitated sucrose solutions — Physics of Fluids 35(6):064120 (Hartge, Flöter y Vilgis) (2023)
  3. Science of Candy: What is Sugar? — Exploratorium
  4. Sugar Stages — Exploratorium
  5. Melting behaviour of D-sucrose, D-glucose and D-fructose — Carbohydrate Research 339(13):2267-2273 (Hurtta, Pitkänen y Knuutinen) (2004)
  6. Coating unblanched, raw nuts (US 5,362,505) — Patente de Procter & Gamble (Google Patents) (1994)

More from the blog

See the whole blog →