Fede Cocina

Common mistakes

Why Didn't My Bread Rise? Causes and How to Test Your Yeast

By 5 min read

In short

If your bread didn't rise in two hours, it's almost always the yeast: water that was too hot killed it (it starts dying around 49 °C (120 °F) and dies completely at 60 °C (140 °F)), or it was already dead from age or poor storage. Use warm water, 40 to 46 °C (105 to 115 °F). To test it, add warm water and a pinch of sugar: if it foams, it's alive. Cold doesn't kill it: it just sleeps.

You covered it, left it next to the heater for two hours. And the dough looks exactly like it did when you kneaded it: not a centimeter taller.

Should you wait longer? Sometimes. But if nothing happened in two hours, the problem is almost always something else: the yeast.

What yeast does (and why it can die)

Yeast is a living thing. It eats the sugars in flour and gives off a gas that forms the little bubbles that make bread rise. If you want the details of how it works and what happens to it in the oven, I explain it in does yeast die when baking.

And since it's alive, it can also die too soon. There are three suspects.

Cause 1: water that's too hot

It's the most common mistake, and it comes from an idea that sounds logical but is wrong: "if it rises with warm water, it'll rise faster with hot water." No: hot water kills it.

According to Bob's Red Mill, a U.S. flour brand, whatever yeast you use, if the water reaches 49 °C (120 °F) or more it begins to die off, and at 60 °C (140 °F) it's completely killed. Cook's Illustrated gives a similar range: between 54 and 60 °C (130 and 140 °F), yeast dies rapidly.

King Arthur Baking agrees that if dough didn't rise, the most likely causes are water hotter than 59 °C (139 °F) or yeast that was stored badly.

How warm should the water be?

To proof dry yeast, Bob's Red Mill gives 40 to 46 °C (105 to 115 °F), and the yeast brand Red Star recommends 43 to 46 °C (110 to 115 °F). That's just barely warm, nothing that burns.

If you don't have a thermometer, do what I do: test the water on your wrist, which is more sensitive than your fingers. It should feel just slightly warm. If it feels hot to you, it's too hot for the yeast.

Cause 2: the yeast was already dead

Sometimes the water was perfect and the yeast was already no good. It ages, and if it's stored badly, it dies sooner.

Red Star says to store unopened jars at room temperature, away from heat, and to use them before the date on the label, which is two years after packaging. Once opened, they go in the fridge or, better, the freezer, and should be used within 4 months. Write the date on the jar when you open it.

How to tell if it's alive: the foam test

Before you risk all your flour, test it:

  1. Put a little yeast in warm water.
  2. Add a pinch of sugar, so it has something to eat.
  3. Wait about 10 minutes.

According to Bob's Red Mill, the sign of lively yeast is little bubbles on the surface of the water. If it foamed, it's good. If after 10 minutes nothing has happened, don't use it: it won't rise.

Red Star also recommends dissolving it this way, in warm liquid with sugar, because it gives the yeast a good start.

Does salt kill yeast?

You hear it a lot, but in a normal recipe, no. King Arthur explains that salt is about 2 % of the flour weight, and it's in contact with the yeast for only a few minutes before mixing.

What salt does do is pull a little water out of the yeast cells, which slow down for a while and then recover. And slowing yeast is a good thing: fermentation moves at a controlled pace. Salt also strengthens gluten and helps the crust brown.

Sue Gray, King Arthur's director of research, says a lot of salt with very little yeast, left together, could harm it, but not in the amounts used for baking. Even so, I dissolve the yeast in the water and add the salt with the flour: it costs nothing.

Cause 3: the kitchen is cold

If it's cold, the yeast didn't die: it's asleep. Bob's Red Mill puts it this way: if it's too cold, yeast simply remains dormant.

In that case, give it more time, or find it a warmer spot, like the oven turned off with the light on. Warm, not hot: don't try to rush it.

Summary: what happened to your bread

What happenedLikely causeWhat to do next time
No rise at all, and you used hot waterThe water killed itWarm water, 40 to 46 °C (105 to 115 °F)
No rise at all, and the water was fineOld or badly stored yeastTest it first with warm water and sugar
It rose, but very slowlyCold kitchenMore time or a warmer spot

To try it with something that always works, check out my sandwich bread: if the yeast is alive and the water is warm, it'll rise every time.

Frequently asked questions

How long should bread dough rise?

It depends on the recipe and how warm your kitchen is, but if nothing happened in two hours, the yeast is most likely dead, not short on time.

Can you use expired yeast?

It may still work, but less. Test it first in warm water with a pinch of sugar: if it doesn't foam in about 10 minutes, don't use it.

Where should you store opened dry yeast?

In the fridge or, better, the freezer, tightly closed. Red Star recommends using it within 4 months of opening.

Can you save dough that didn't rise?

If the yeast died, it won't rise on its own. Test some fresh yeast in warm water and, if it's alive, work it into the dough by kneading again.

Related recipes

Sources

The facts in this post come from these sources (checked when it was written).

  1. What Temperature Kills Yeast? — Bob's Red Mill
  2. The Impact of Too-Hot Water on Yeast — Cook's Illustrated (America's Test Kitchen)
  3. Does salt kill yeast? — King Arthur Baking (Jessica Battilana) (2023)
  4. Active Dry Yeast — Red Star Yeast

More from the blog

See the whole blog →