Kitchen science
Why Is Carrot Cake So Moist? The Carrots, the Oil, and the Math
By Fede4 min readUpdated
In short
Carrot cake is moist because of the carrots: they're 88 % water, like milk, and in a cake with 300 g of carrots and 3 eggs they add about 265 g of water versus 114 g from the eggs. Grating and baking break open their cells and release that juice into the crumb. Oil helps too: it stays liquid at room temperature, so the crumb feels moister than with butter.
Try this on someone: "In my carrot cake, what adds more water, the three eggs or the carrots?" Almost everyone says the eggs. And they lose by a mile.
The moist crumb of this cake isn't magic or a secret ingredient: it's water hidden inside the carrots, plus a detail about the fat that almost nobody notices. Here are both, with numbers.
Carrots are 88 % water
According to the USDA's food database, raw carrots are 88.29 % water. Whole milk is 88.13 %. In other words, when it comes to water, a carrot is practically milk, just locked inside a hard vegetable.
The math with my recipe
My cake uses 300 g of carrots and 3 eggs. I ran the numbers with USDA averages, assuming a large egg weighs about 50 g out of the shell and is 76.15 % water:
| Ingredient | Amount | Water | Water it adds |
|---|---|---|---|
| Carrots | 300 g | 88 % | ≈ 265 g |
| Eggs | 3 (≈ 150 g) | 76 % | ≈ 114 g |
| Oil | 100 g | 0 % | 0 g |
The carrots add more than twice as much water as the eggs. One caveat: the math assumes you weigh the carrots already peeled; if you weigh them with the peel, it comes out a little lower.
Why you have to grate them
All that water is inside the carrot's cells, and a whole carrot holds on to it very well. Every cut breaks the cells on the surface: a study on cut carrots found that the duller the blade, the more it damages the tissue. When you grate a carrot, you multiply the cuts.
Then, in the oven, heat does the rest. A scientific review on how fruits and vegetables are processed explains that heat damages the cell membranes, the cells lose the pressure that keeps them firm (called turgor), and the tissue softens. That juice stays inside the crumb.
And it doesn't stop when the cake comes out of the oven: King Arthur Baking notes that as the cake sits, the carrots keep releasing moisture.
The twist: butter has water and oil doesn't
Here's the part almost nobody knows. According to the USDA, butter is 16 % water, and oil is 0 %. If it all came down to water, the butter cake should be the moister one.
It's the other way around, and the reason is temperature. Oil stays liquid at room temperature; butter firms up as it cools. America's Test Kitchen puts it this way: an all-butter cake seems drier, and an oil cake feels moist even though it actually isn't. It's a feeling in your mouth, not extra water.
ATK adds another advantage: oil slows down the firming of the starch, the same thing that happens with bread going stale. That's why oil cakes taste moist for several days.
Do the carrots sweeten it?
Less than you'd think. According to the USDA, raw carrots have 4.73 g of sugars per 100 g: in 300 g, that's about 14 g. My cake has 200 g of sugar. The carrots bring moisture, color, and texture; the sweetness comes from the sugar.
My tips for a moist carrot cake
- Oil, not butter. That's what my recipe uses: 100 g. I save the butter for greasing the pan.
- Box grater or food processor. By hand it takes a while; a food processor that does the grating for you is much faster.
- The toothpick can come out moist. When you test it, what matters is that it doesn't come out with raw batter stuck to it. Moist is fine: the cake should be moist inside.
- If your peeled carrots turn whitish, don't worry: the surface just dried out. A study on peeled carrots found that dipping them in water brings back part of their color.
- Frosting is optional. In my recipe I keep it simple, but the classic is a cream cheese frosting with powdered sugar. If you want to make the cream cheese at home, I explain it in homemade cream cheese.
The full steps, the pan, and the baking times are in my carrot cake recipe.
The short version: the grated carrots bring the moisture, the oil brings the moist feel, and a damp toothpick isn't a mistake: it's the sign you got it right.
Frequently asked questions
Should carrot cake be made with oil or butter?
The classic, and what I use, is oil. Even though butter is 16 % water and oil has none, oil stays liquid at room temperature and the crumb feels moister.
How much water is in a carrot?
Raw carrots are 88 % water according to the USDA, practically the same as whole milk.
Why do peeled carrots turn white?
Because the surface dries out. They haven't gone bad: dipping them in water brings back part of their color.
How do you know when carrot cake is done?
Test it with a toothpick: if it comes out with raw batter stuck to it, it needs more time. If it just comes out damp, it's ready, because it should stay moist inside.
Does carrot cake dry out the next day?
Less than most cakes: the carrots keep releasing moisture as it sits, and oil cakes taste moist for several days.
Related recipes
Sources
The facts in this post come from these sources (checked when it was written).
- Cómo hacer torta de zanahoria — Fede Cocina (YouTube)
- Carrots, raw (FDC 170393) — USDA FoodData Central (SR Legacy)
- Milk, whole, 3.25% milkfat (FDC 171265) — USDA FoodData Central (SR Legacy)
- Egg, whole, raw, fresh (FDC 171287) — USDA FoodData Central (SR Legacy)
- Butter, without salt (FDC 173430) — USDA FoodData Central (SR Legacy)
- Quality and shelf-life of fresh cut carrot slices as affected by slicing method — Journal of Food Science 63(5):851-856 (Barry-Ryan y O'Beirne) (1998)
- Thermal, High Pressure, and Electric Field Processing Effects on Plant Cell Membrane Integrity and Relevance to Fruit and Vegetable Quality — Journal of Food Science 75(7):R121-R130 (Gonzalez y Barrett) (2010)
- Next-Level Yellow Sheet Cake — America's Test Kitchen (A. Geary) (2020)
- Olive Oil Cake — America's Test Kitchen (A. Geary) (2017)
- Wait, should I be aging my cakes? — King Arthur Baking (R. Anastopoulo) (2022)
- Mechanism of surface white discoloration of peeled (minimally processed) carrots during storage — Italian Journal of Food Science (Cisneros-Zevallos, Saltveit y Krochta) (1995)
