Kitchen science
Shiny or Dull Side of Aluminum Foil: Does It Matter?
By Fede4 min readUpdated
In short
With regular aluminum foil, the side doesn't matter: the shiny and dull finishes come from how it's made, because two sheets are rolled together at the end and the side touching the rollers comes out shiny. In America's Test Kitchen's tests, the temperature difference was about 1 °C (2 °F) at most. The one exception is nonstick foil, which has the coating on one side only: that side goes against the food.
Some kitchen arguments split families. One of the oldest: which side of aluminum foil goes where? Some swear the shiny side goes in, because it reflects heat toward the food. Others swear it's the other way around.
Well: everyone's wrong. Nobody made that difference on purpose, and in the oven it barely changes anything.
Why does foil have a shiny side and a dull side?
Because of how it's made. Aluminum foil is made by pressing the metal between rollers, over and over, until it's as thin as a sheet of paper. That process is called rolling, or milling.
The problem shows up at the end: the sheet gets so thin that if it went through the rollers alone, it would tear. So on the last pass, two sheets are rolled together, one on top of the other.
That's where the difference comes from. According to Reynolds, one of the best-known foil brands in the U.S., the shiny side is the one milled without touching another sheet of metal, meaning the side that touches the rollers. And the side that was in contact with the other sheet is the dull one.
The same company told America's Test Kitchen that the shine is simply a result of the manufacturing process. There's no "inside" side and "outside" side.
Does one side cook differently?
The shiny-side theory sounds logical: if it shines, it reflects, and if it reflects, it sends heat back toward the food. But America's Test Kitchen tested it three different ways, with one package wrapped shiny side out and another shiny side in:
| Test | What they did | Result |
|---|---|---|
| Potatoes | Two potatoes of the same weight, 1 hour at 175 °C (350 °F) | Both reached 92 °C (198 °F) inside |
| Water | Two beakers of water at 22 °C (71 °F), 30 minutes at 175 °C (350 °F) | Shiny side in: about 1 °C (2 °F) hotter |
| Cold mashed potatoes | Two covered 20 × 20 cm (8 × 8 in) glass pans, 45 minutes | Shiny side in: about 1 °C (2 °F) hotter |
A one-degree difference, at best. Their conclusion was that the two sides are pretty much interchangeable. Food Republic, citing those tests, says the same: which side faces out doesn't significantly change how quickly food heats up.
In other words: that degree won't change how anything cooks. What does matter is covering the pan well, sealing the packet tightly, and sticking to the recipe's timing.
The one exception: nonstick foil
There's nonstick aluminum foil, which comes with a coating so food doesn't stick. And that coating is on one side only. Reynolds explained it to America's Test Kitchen this way: there's no difference between the sides, except with nonstick foil, which may only be nonstick on one side.
In that case, the coated side goes against the food. Which side that is depends on the brand, so check the box: it tells you.
When you shouldn't use aluminum foil
What really matters isn't the side, but what you wrap. Germany's Federal Institute for Risk Assessment (BfR) says aluminum foil isn't suitable for storing, heating, or keeping warm acidic or salty foods. It gives concrete examples:
- cut apples;
- tomatoes;
- rhubarb;
- salted or marinated fish;
- cheese.
According to the BfR, using aluminum the wrong way can lead to a comparatively high intake of aluminum. For those foods, I use parchment paper or a container with a lid. If you want to make fish with lemon in a packet, build it with parchment.
What I do use it for (and the side doesn't matter)
- Covering edges that brown too fast on a cake or a tart.
- Covering a baking dish so the top doesn't dry out before the inside is cooked.
- Making the insulating strip for a sponge cake: damp towels wrapped in foil around the pan. I explain it in why cakes dome in the middle.
In none of those cases does the side matter. So with regular foil, use whichever side you like. With nonstick, check the box. And with acidic or salty food, reach for a different wrap.
Frequently asked questions
Does the shiny side of aluminum foil reflect more heat?
In America's Test Kitchen's tests, with the shiny side in, the food ended up about 1 °C (2 °F) hotter at most. In practice, it doesn't change how food cooks.
Which side of nonstick aluminum foil goes against the food?
The side with the nonstick coating. It depends on the brand, so check the box.
Can you wrap food with lemon or tomato in aluminum foil?
It's better not to. Germany's BfR says aluminum foil isn't suitable for storing or heating acidic or salty foods. Use parchment paper or a lidded container.
Can you store cheese in aluminum foil?
The BfR lists cheese among the salty foods that shouldn't be wrapped in aluminum foil. Parchment, plastic wrap, or a sealed container work better.
Sources
The facts in this post come from these sources (checked when it was written).
- Why Using The Shiny Side Of Tin Foil Doesn't Actually Matter — Food Republic
- The Great Aluminum Foil Debate: Shiny Side Up or Down? — America's Test Kitchen (Alyssa Vaughn) (2022)
- FAQs about aluminium in food and products intended for consumers — BfR, Instituto Federal de Evaluación de Riesgos (Alemania) (2020)



