Fede Cocina

Kitchen science

Why Do Sweet Recipes Call for a Pinch of Salt?

By 4 min readUpdated

In short

Sweet recipes call for a pinch of salt because salt suppresses bitterness much more than it suppresses sweetness. Many sweet things have a bitter background (chocolate, dark caramel, coffee) that masks the sweetness; once it's muted, the sweetness comes through without extra sugar. In one study, sodium salts cut the bitterness of a compound by over 70 %. But it's a pinch: if you can taste the salt, you overdid it.

You're about to make brownies and the recipe calls for "a pinch of salt." In something sweet. It looks like a typo, or the whim of a cook who lost their mind.

It's neither. That pinch is one of the things that changes the result the most, and there's a really neat bit of science behind it.

What does salt do in sweet recipes?

It mutes bitterness. Many sweet things carry some hidden bitterness: dark caramel, coffee, cocoa, and dark chocolate, which in Spanish we literally call "bitter chocolate" for a reason.

And bitterness, as you'd expect, masks sweetness. When salt brings the bitterness down, the sweetness that was hiding underneath comes through. That's why a brownie with its pinch of salt tastes more chocolatey and sweeter, without a single extra gram of sugar.

Salt works like a filter

For years there was an odd contradiction. In the kitchen, everybody knew salt enhances flavor. But in the lab, almost every study showed that salt either suppresses other tastes or does nothing to them.

Two researchers at the Monell Chemical Senses Center, a U.S. institute that studies taste and smell, offered the explanation in 1997, in the journal Nature: salt filters flavors. It suppresses unpleasant tastes, like bitterness, far more than pleasant ones, like sweetness. So the pleasant ones stand out more.

The lab result: over 70 % less bitterness

In 2001, the same team published another study with several salts and several bitter compounds. With urea, a bitter compound used in this kind of test, sodium salts cut bitterness by over 70 %.

But it doesn't work the same with everything. With magnesium sulfate, also bitter, the bitterness didn't drop at all. And here's a detail I love: sodium is what does the job. In that study, potassium didn't suppress bitterness at all, so salt substitutes made with potassium chloride shouldn't pull off this trick.

The researchers concluded that the effect happens on the tongue, at the taste receptors, and isn't a trick of the mind.

Sweeter without more sugar

In the same study they ran a second test: a mixture that was bitter and sweet at once, like chocolate. When they cut the bitterness with a sodium salt, the mixture tasted sweeter.

Their conclusion reads almost like a recipe: adding salt doesn't just add saltiness, it boosts flavor, because it suppresses the unpleasant tastes (like bitter) and lifts the ones we like (like sweet).

But it's a pinch

The goal isn't a dessert that tastes salty. The pinch should stay hidden: you don't notice it, but you miss it when it's gone. If you can taste the salt, you overdid it.

A pinch is what you can grab between the tips of two fingers. Salty-sweet on purpose is a different story, like salted caramel, where you're supposed to taste the salt.

Which salt to use

For sweets, fine salt. The King Arthur Baking test kitchen uses table salt because its small crystals dissolve more evenly into the dough, so the salt is spread out well.

If you weigh your salt, the type doesn't matter: a gram is a gram. It does matter if you measure with spoons, because coarse or flaky salts take up more room: King Arthur says that with Diamond Crystal kosher salt you need double the volume.

What if I use salted butter?

Then there's already salt in there. According to America's Test Kitchen, salted butter contains 1.6 to 2.5 % added salt, and the amount varies by brand. That's why, for baking, they prefer unsalted butter: that way you control the salt.

If all you have is salted butter, skip the recipe's pinch or use less.

Where you notice it most

  • Chocolate and cocoa: brownies, loaf cakes, chocolate cakes. This is where it shows the most.
  • Caramel and dulce de leche: the darker the caramel, the more bitterness there is to mute. I explain it in how caramel is made.
  • Coffee: coffee desserts, creams, and cakes.
  • Cookies: the pinch of salt is what keeps you from stopping at one, like in my chocolate chip cookies.

To try it yourself, make these brownies twice, once with the pinch and once without. The difference is huge. So next time a sweet recipe asks for salt, don't skip it.

Frequently asked questions

What happens if you leave the salt out of a sweet recipe?

It still works, but with less flavor: the bitterness of the chocolate, caramel, or coffee masks more of the sweetness, and the result tastes flat.

Does potassium salt substitute work in desserts?

Not for this effect: in the 2001 study, sodium suppressed bitterness and potassium didn't suppress it at all.

Can you use coarse salt in sweet recipes?

Fine salt is better, since it dissolves more evenly in the dough. If you weigh it, the type of salt doesn't change the amount.

How much salt is in salted butter?

According to America's Test Kitchen, 1.6 to 2.5 % added salt, and it varies by brand.

Related recipes

Sources

The facts in this post come from these sources (checked when it was written).

  1. Salt enhances flavour by suppressing bitterness — Nature 387 (P. A. S. Breslin y G. K. Beauchamp, Monell Chemical Senses Center), resumen en IDEAS/RePEc (1997)
  2. Suppression of Bitterness Using Sodium Salts — CHIMIA 55 (R. S. J. Keast, P. A. S. Breslin y G. K. Beauchamp) (2001)
  3. Is there a best salt for baking? — King Arthur Baking (Rossi Anastopoulo) (2021)
  4. Butter facts — America's Test Kitchen

More from the blog

See the whole blog →