Fede Cocina

Kitchen science

Why Water Doesn't Help With Spicy Food (and Milk Does)

By 4 min read

In short

Water barely helps with spicy food because capsaicin, the compound that makes chiles hot, behaves like an oil: water doesn't dissolve it and just spreads it around. In a Penn State study of seven drinks, whole milk and skim milk cut the burn the most, and skim worked just as well: what helps is milk's protein, not its fat. Carbonated drinks did poorly, and alcohol makes it worse.

You went overboard with the chile, your mouth is on fire, and you grab a glass of water. You drink, and two seconds later it burns just the same, or worse. And someone always says, "drink milk."

They're right. But almost nobody knows why, and the explanation everyone repeats is wrong.

Spicy food doesn't burn (even though it feels like it)

First, something few people know: your mouth isn't actually burning. What makes a chile hot is a compound called capsaicin, which latches onto the exact sensor you use to detect heat.

That sensor is called TRPV1, and discovering it earned David Julius the 2021 Nobel Prize in Medicine. According to the University of Gothenburg, Julius identified a sensor in the nerve endings of the skin that responds to heat, and he found it precisely by experimenting with capsaicin.

So the sensor tells your brain something is burning you, even though there's no heat at all. And your body reacts as if it were real: you sweat, your eyes water, and your nose runs. It happens on the skin too, which is why it stings if you touch your eyes after cutting a chile.

Why doesn't water work?

Because capsaicin behaves like an oil. Water can't dissolve it, so it doesn't wash it away: it spreads it all over your mouth, reaching more sensors.

To be fair: in the study I describe below, every drink reduced the burn somewhat, water included. But it was far behind the ones that worked best.

The seven-drink study

In 2019, researchers at Penn State tested it with 72 people. Each one drank a sip of spicy tomato juice mix spiked with capsaicin, then a test drink, and rated the burn every 10 seconds for 2 minutes. They published the results in the journal Physiology and Behavior.

DrinkHow it did
Whole milkAmong the biggest reductions
Skim milkNearly as good as whole
Cherry Kool-AidAlso among the best
WaterReduced the burn somewhat, much less than milk
ColaPoorly
SeltzerPoorly
Non-alcoholic beerPoorly, because of the carbonation

The researchers' conclusion was simple: to reduce the burn, choose milk, and it doesn't matter whether it's whole or skim.

Is it the fat? Nope

The usual explanation is that the fat in milk "carries away" the capsaicin. But if it were the fat, skim milk shouldn't have worked almost as well as whole.

Alissa Nolden, one of the authors, said they didn't expect skim milk to be as effective, and that this suggests protein matters more than fat. According to Food Republic, casein, milk's main protein, can free the TRPV1 receptors from the capsaicin molecules that latch onto them. The fat explanation, they say, is an oversimplification.

Sweet drinks don't remove the burn, they mask it

Kool-Aid did very well, but for a different reason. The researchers think it doesn't remove the capsaicin: the sweetness overwhelms the burn instead. It's a flavor trick similar to salt muting bitterness.

Carbonation makes it worse; alcohol, worse still

The carbonated drinks did poorly, as the researchers expected. So did the non-alcoholic beer, because of the bubbles.

And if it has alcohol, it's worse: according to Nolden, ethanol amplifies the sensation. So an ice-cold beer with spicy food is a bad way to put out the fire.

How to tame the heat before you eat

Better than putting out the fire is not starting it. And here's another myth: the heat isn't in the seeds.

According to Food Republic, the real source of the heat is the placenta, the soft white membrane inside the chile, which connects to the capsaicin glands. The seeds barely carry any heat, only from sitting next to that membrane. That's why shaking the seeds out doesn't make a chile any milder.

  • Remove the white ribs: cut off the stem, halve the chile, and scrape the inside with a small spoon.
  • The hotter the chile, the bigger that membrane, so it pays off most with the hottest ones.
  • Wear gloves, especially when removing the seeds and ribs.
  • Don't touch your eyes while cutting: chile juice stings.

Bottom line

If you overdid the heat on some tacos or enchiladas, go straight for milk, whole or skim. If there's none, something sweet helps. Water barely does anything, and anything with bubbles or alcohol is better left for later.

Frequently asked questions

Does yogurt help with spicy food?

It's a dairy product with the same proteins as milk, which are what pull capsaicin off the sensors. The Penn State study only tested milk, but the idea is the same.

Are chile seeds what makes them spicy?

No. The hottest part is the white membrane inside, the placenta. The seeds are only a little spicy because they were attached to it.

Why do your eyes burn after cutting chiles?

Because capsaicin also activates the sensors in your skin and eyes. Wear gloves and don't touch your face while cutting.

Does beer help with spicy food?

No. The carbonation doesn't help, and alcohol amplifies the burning sensation.

Related recipes

Sources

The facts in this post come from these sources (checked when it was written).

  1. Sense of heat and touch: the Medicine Prize recognizes important physiological functions — Universidad de Gotemburgo (2021)
  2. Why Water Sucks At Cooling Spicy Sensations — Food Republic
  3. Milk is best drink to reduce burn from chili peppers — Penn State News (2019)
  4. Proteins in milk, not just fat, may help reduce oral burn from spicy food — Penn State News (2024)
  5. How To Actually Cut The Spice Out Of A Pepper (Hint: It's Not All In The Seeds) — Food Republic (Andrew Housman) (2023)

More from the blog

See the whole blog →